Alternatives: Music Streaming
You'll most likely using Spotify or similar, to stream music. Here are reasons why I think you should switch to a more ethical streaming service.
Reasons why Spotify is bad:
- Artist compensation: Spotify’s royalty system is based on stream share, and money generally flows first to rights holders, who then pay artists under their agreements. That can make it hard for us to know what a particular artist actually earns per stream.
- Rising subscription costs: Price increases make the service less attractive if you don’t feel the features justify the cost.
- Spotify’s open approach to AI music: Listeners can't tell if what they’re hearing is AI and human artists have to compete for attention and royalties. AI tools are used to produce music at scale, crowding recommendations and making impersonation or fake uploads easier.
- Spotify’s CEO invests in AI military tech: Daniel Ek (CEO) is investing €600 million in Helsing, a defense company developing AI-enabled military technology. Some artists and listeners object to that association and have called for a boycott.
If you want a change, here are a few routes:
- Qobuz: a paid streaming service known for high-quality audio, with a store where you can buy and download albums
- Bandcamp: buy music straight from artists and download files you keep
- Tidal: another paid streaming service that focuses on sound quality
- Your own music library: apps like Navidrome or Jellyfin can stream music you own from your own computer, though they take more setup
I use Qobuz, I really enjoy their ethics and commitment to artists. I'm happy paying for a subscription service to stream music, knowing it's going to a independent company who values artists.
Why change to Qobuz?
- Independently owned, not part of a multinational tech conglomerate: They state they are family-owned, with employees as shareholders.
- Transparency about artist payouts: Qobuz publishes an audited average of $0.01873 per stream, the highest payout for artists of all streaming services, references below. That money goes to labels and publishers first, so it isn’t a guaranteed amount an individual artist receives but is the best payout right now.
- Human-led music discovery: Its editorial playlists, reviews, and recommendations are curated by music specialists.
- A stated commitment to artists over AI content farms: Qobuz says it identifies and labels AI-generated music, excludes identified tracks from recommendations, and won’t generate music to fill its catalog. It does use AI for some tasks, such as translation and operational support, so it isn’t AI-free.
- High-quality audio: It offers lossless CD-quality and Hi-Res streaming, up to 24-bit. You’ll benefit most with good headphones, speakers, or a Hi-Fi setup.
- Doesn't invest in AI military tech (a specific reason to leave Spotify).
If human curation and smaller, less-conglomerate ownership are your priorities, Qobuz is probably the closest fit among full-catalog streaming services: it is family-owned and independently operated, with employees as shareholders, and its editorial curation is human-led.
Payouts by platform:
| Platform | Paid per 1,000 streams | Per stream | Streams to earn $1,000 | Source and year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qobuz | $18.73 | $0.01873 | About 53,400 | Qobuz, fiscal 2024, independently reviewed |
| Amazon Music | $8.80 | $0.0088 | About 113,600 | Duetti, 2024 |
| Tidal | $6.80 | $0.0068 | About 147,100 | Duetti, 2024 |
| Apple Music | $6.20 | $0.0062 | About 161,300 | Duetti, 2024 |
| YouTube | $4.80 | $0.0048 | About 208,300 | Duetti, 2024 |
| Deezer | $4.80 | $0.0048 | About 208,300 | Duetti, 2024 |
| Pandora | $3.20 | $0.0032 | About 312,500 | Duetti, 2024 |
| Spotify | $3.00 | $0.0030 | About 333,300 | Duetti, 2024 |
| Napster | Closed January 2026 | None | Not applicable | Service no longer streams music |
Average payouts to recording rights holders in US dollars. Sources: Duetti Music Economics Report (independent artists’ royalty statements, 2024) and Qobuz’s disclosed rate for its 2024 fiscal year. TikTok, at $0.50, is paid per video created and is left out.
There are other open-source apps out there that you can use such as Nuclear Music Player. But I choose not to use them as I want to support artists if I can do so in an ethical way.